Back to U.S.

Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, asked if Israel should stop being a Jewish state: 'I don't believe in ethno-states'

FACTS

Michigan's Democratic senator-elect, Abdul El-Sayed, went on NBC's "Meet the Press" on Sunday and would not say that Israel should remain a Jewish state, Fox News reported.

What he said (per Fox News, from the NBC interview): - Host Kristen Welker asked him directly: "Are you saying that Israel should no longer exist as a Jewish state?" He answered: "I'm saying that I don't believe in ethno-states. I'm saying I believe in equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination." - "We've been told for a very long time that Israel is a Jewish democratic state, and I think folks are having to choose, is it a Jewish state or a democratic state?" he said. "I would argue based on our principles that we should always be putting democracy over everything else." - Welker pointed out that 43 countries identify with a particular religion, among them Pakistan, an Islamic republic, and Denmark, which is constitutionally Christian. She asked why the world's only Jewish state should give up its national identity. El-Sayed said: "Well, I don't believe in ethno-states generally. I don't think we should be in the business of funding the military of Pakistan either."

The pushback: Rabbi Yaakov Menken of the Coalition for Jewish Values told Fox News Digital that El-Sayed "only attacks the one country in the Middle East that provides the equal rights to peace, dignity, and self-determination that he claims to support." Menken also noted that most of historic Palestine is now Jordan, which has had no Jewish residents since 1948.

The video: El-Sayed's full answer is in our Shorts.

Why it matters: El-Sayed takes his Senate seat in January. Asked a yes-or-no question about the world's only Jewish state, he would not say yes.

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 25m ago

    Published.