Jennifer Sey, founder of the women's sports apparel company XX-XY Athletics, is asking a federal appeals court to block a Colorado law she says could punish her business for calling male athletes male, Fox News reports.
The 2025 Kelly Loving Act expanded the state's anti-discrimination law to cover a person's chosen name and how they choose to be addressed. Sey's lawyers at Alliance Defending Freedom say that could force businesses to use pronouns and honorifics that conflict with their beliefs. Violations can bring fines of up to $3,500 each, and some advertising violations are a misdemeanor punishable by up to 120 days in jail.
The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments Monday. A lower court judge denied a preliminary injunction in March, finding the company had not shown a credible threat of enforcement. Colorado says it has taken no action against the company.
"Then why do you have the law? I mean, I don't trust you," Sey said, calling the state's position a "trust me, bro, defense."
"The Supreme Court has been clear time and again that Americans don't have to wait to be prosecuted to challenge unconstitutional laws," ADF senior counsel Hal Frampton said.
The suit cites a company post about a male athlete in Pennsylvania girls' high school track: "When boys run girls' track, they win. And girls lose." A lawyer for the state accused the plaintiffs in court of seeking the right "to misgender and deadname anyone with impunity."
Sey, a former national gymnastics champion, helped lead this month's winning campaign for Colorado's Proposition 134, which passed with about 52% and requires school and college teams to be designated male, female or coed based generally on biological sex. "Given the speech restrictions, how can we even talk about the law itself?" she said.
SOURCES
UPDATES
7:33 PM ET
Published.
