Back to U.S.

Opinion: Byron York — Democrats spent a year warning democracy was ending. Then they won the midterms.

FACTS

Byron York, in a Washington Examiner Daily Memo, points to a midterm exit-poll finding that got less attention than the economy: when voters were asked which issue was most important facing the country, "the state of democracy" ranked second, ahead of healthcare, immigration, foreign policy and crime.

The people who named democracy, York writes, were not Republicans still angry about 2020. Eighty percent of them voted for Democrats; 19% voted for Republicans. "Worrying about the state of American democracy, it appears, is a Democratic avocation."

And they were, at that moment, on their way to a large victory in both chambers. York argues the election itself was evidence that American democracy was "fine" — after a year of warnings that President Trump would rig the midterms or cancel them.

He cites Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, who in October 2025 likened Trump to authoritarian regimes and, a year later, claimed the president had "settled on a strategy" in which "if he can't win Americans' support, he'll try to cancel their vote." Rep. Seth Moulton, York notes, told a podcast the "most likely scenario" was that Trump would "disrupt the midterms, cancel them, delay them."

The New York Times, after the votes were counted, published an essay headlined "Perhaps the Rumors of Democracy's Demise Were Premature," asking whether the midterm had "saved" democracy. York's answer is no: "Democracy wasn't lost to begin with."

The scare, he concludes, was politically useful. "One of the lessons they will undoubtedly take from their victory is that scaring voters works."

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. Nov 17 · 11:47 PM ET

    Published.