Back to Elections

OPINION: Democratic states' plot to get around the Electoral College is an unconstitutional power grab

FACTS

David Harsanyi argues in the New York Post that the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which Democrats are pushing after their midterm gains, is a way to get around the Constitution instead of amending it.

Under the compact, member states pledge to give all their electoral votes to whichever ticket wins the national popular vote, no matter how their own voters chose. Harsanyi writes that 17 states with 222 electoral votes have joined, that it needs 270 to take effect, and that after Democrats expanded their control of state legislatures and governorships this month, "they probably have enough."

His main points: - The founders debated many systems and explicitly rejected a popular vote. The compact would force electors to vote against the candidate their own state picked. - The Electoral College makes candidates appeal and govern nationally. "Forty states have smaller populations than Los Angeles County," he notes. - Because states run their own elections, a national vote total would put the whole country at the mercy of rules set by states like California. - The "popular vote" is "the gross score of a game that hasn't been played," since campaigns compete in 51 separate contests.

He argues Democratic governors would never honor the pact if a Republican won the popular vote but lost the Electoral College, and that any "constitutionally mindful Supreme Court" would strike it down. "How long can a constitutional republic exist if states can enter into pacts for the purpose of ignoring the parts of the Constitution they don't like?" he asks.

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 3:46 AM ET

    Published.