In a Jerusalem Post opinion piece, Aliza Pilichowski, who has lived in Mitzpe Yeriho, 20 minutes from Jerusalem, for more than a decade, takes aim at the Western formula, repeated recently by Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong, that there can be "no peace without two states."
Pilichowski argues that the record points the other way: Arab leaders rejected the 1947 UN partition plan and went to war, and Yasser Arafat walked away from the Camp David offer in 2000, which included a capital in eastern Jerusalem and most of the West Bank, before the second intifada killed thousands. Former President Bill Clinton, she notes, has said repeatedly that Arafat turned down a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
She writes that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is the only one where the winning side keeps offering land, recognition and aid to the side that started and lost each war, and cites Alan Dershowitz's argument that terror must carry a cost, including permanent loss of territory, so that violence is not rewarded.
She also points to 2026 Gallup polling showing that only 26% of Israelis and 32% of Palestinians in the West Bank and eastern Jerusalem still back an independent Palestinian state, and argues that real peace starts with Palestinian acceptance of Israel's permanence as a Jewish state.
SOURCES
UPDATES
7:18 AM ET
Published.