Back to Israel

OPINION: Anti-Zionism's next frontier is calling for Western military action against Israel

FACTS

Adam Levick, UK media research manager for CAMERA, argues in The Jerusalem Post that the anti-Israel movement has no limiting principle, and that its rhetoric is now moving from boycotts and "genocide" libels to open calls for Western countries to use force against the Jewish state.

Levick notes that few prominent anti-Israel activists or groups ever issued a clear, no-caveats condemnation of the October 7 massacre, and that protest slogans such as "From the River to the Sea" made plain they shared Hamas's goal of erasing Israel, even when they didn't cheer the attack itself.

He points to three recent examples: - In September, British Labour MP Tahir Ali, who called the U.S.-Israel war on Iran "illegal," called for British "military action" against Israel in a House of Commons debate and said Israel should be forced to disarm. He apologized only under pressure from his party. - Earlier this month, French presidential candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon, whose France Unbowed party says it rejects Western military intervention, pledged at a rally to take direct military action regarding Israel if elected, including sending French Navy ships to challenge Israel's blockade of Gaza. - A week ago, anti-Zionist writer Benjamin Moser said on a podcast that Israel will and should be destroyed "militarily and economically."

Citing Israeli writer Shany Mor, Levick argues that October 7 didn't make Israel's critics recoil. It pushed them to inflate Israel's "imagined malevolence" so their worldview could survive. "Calling on Western armies to confront Israel militarily," he concludes, "is merely the latest manifestation of a movement consumed by a pathological hatred that requires the total dehumanization of its target to justify its own extremism."

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 1:15 AM ET

    Published.