Back to U.S.

OPINION: Nutty NYC pols want to protect lobsters from being boiled. What about the rights of people?

FACTS

New York Post columnist Steve Cuozzo takes aim at a City Council bill that would penalize any restaurant that allows "the placement of a live crustacean into boiling liquid for the purpose of cooking or preparing such crustacean for human consumption."

"Boiling live lobsters is cruel — never mind that the primitive creatures have no brains and can't complain on TikTok or mount a street protest," Cuozzo writes, suggesting the bill's sponsors, Council members Oswald Feliz of the Bronx and Harvey Epstein of Manhattan, "take their places in the pot next time one becomes available."

His main points: - A ban would put lobster-focused restaurants like Red Hook Lobster Pound out of business and cripple scores of others. "Heck, they can always switch to selling tofu!" - The bill would protect any "aquatic invertebrate belonging to the subphylum Crustacea, including, but not limited to, a lobster or crab," from a fast boil, a globally common cooking method. - It fits a pattern from the Council's "increasingly lefty-looney majority": proposed sick days for caring for ailing pets, an elephant-keeping ban, free-range-only egg purchases, and the just-signed ban on Central Park carriage horses, which Epstein championed. - Feliz chairs the Public Safety Committee while his central Bronx district has some of the city's highest violent-crime rates, including homicide. - Epstein and Council member Christopher Marte argued for the carriage-horse ban in a July City & State op-ed that the outlet later found was "partially written with the use of generative artificial intelligence."

"But artificial intelligence has nothing on real-world stupidity," Cuozzo concludes.

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 12:52 PM ET

    Published.