Back to U.S.

Opinion: New York Post editorial board — Mamdani's 'close Rikers' plan barely begins to face reality: 4,100 new beds can't replace a jail holding 6,650

FACTS

The New York Post editorial board says Mayor Zohran Mamdani's revised plan to close Rikers Island, expected Friday, is "still mostly fantasy."

City Hall is starting to admit that the law requiring Rikers to shut down by Aug. 31 next year can't work, because none of the four replacement "borough-based" jails will exist until at least a year after that, the board writes. Even when all four are built, they would hold about 4,100 beds, far short of Rikers' current population of roughly 6,650, so under state law the city still couldn't close the island.

The editorial says the mayor's team has been meeting with district attorneys since summer about cutting the jail population through bail reviews, "diversion" and reentry programs, but that those steps are unlikely to cut the population by a third, and that the population is slowly rising.

"Contrary to progressive myth, Rikers mostly houses hard-core criminals," the board writes, people charged with murder, rape and armed robbery and members of gangs like the Trinitarios and Tren de Aragua, not fare evaders. It warns that City Council progressives would rather "empty out Rikers in August" and that the city's leaders need to face the facts.

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 6:07 AM ET

    Published.