Back to U.S.

OPINION: Forgetting the lessons of Iryna Zarutska's murder

FACTS

The New York Post editorial board argues that Charlotte may win dismissal of the wrongful-death suit over Iryna Zarutska's 2025 murder on a light-rail train, but the record leaves "no question of the city's moral guilt," and North Carolina now looks ready to forget what it learned.

"Fourteen chances to save Iryna's life, all wasted by a blue-city 'justice' system bent on maximum leniency for violent criminals," the board writes.

Its main points: - Charlotte is claiming government immunity for its transit-policing choices, including using private security instead of police on the light rail. Yet the city admits DeCarlos Brown boarded without a ticket and there was no guard on the train when he stabbed the Ukrainian refugee in the neck. - Brown had been arrested and released at least 14 times over more than a decade, for crimes including assault, felony robbery and gun possession, many in Mecklenburg County, where the MacArthur Foundation funded efforts "to continue safely reducing the jail population." - His documented schizophrenia went untreated until after the killing, and the state later used his mental illness as grounds not to try him on charges that could have meant life in prison. - "Iryna's Law," passed in 2025, restricted cashless bail and eased involuntary commitment, but most Democratic lawmakers voted no or abstained, and Democrats just won North Carolina's lower house and near-parity in the upper. "Expect them to roll back those reforms."

The board's conclusion: none of the judges, lawmakers or officials who left Brown free will answer for it. "Get ready for more horrors like the killing of Iryna Zarutska."

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 9:14 AM ET

    Published.