In an editorial, the New York Post argues that Mayor Zohran Mamdani's signing of the Community Opportunity for Purchase Act (COPA) is a test of whether City Hall can get away with "constitution-defying socialism."
Starting Jan. 1, the law covers about 2,100 rent-regulated buildings with enough code violations. When an owner agrees on a price with any buyer, "qualified nonprofits" get 90 days to make an offer, and the owner must sell to them if they match the price. The Post says those nonprofits are "essentially, ones run by Mamdani allies," and that the law's title is misleading: "This isn't creating any opportunity for the community, as the law's title pretends, but only for the interests that control the nonprofit."
The editorial argues tenants gain nothing, since the law "doesn't lower rents, only changes who collects them," and that it cuts the value of the targeted buildings by delaying sales and scaring off private bidders, which means less investment and faster decay. It points to the New York City Housing Authority's repair backlog of nearly $100 billion as a warning about public-minded landlords, and says nonprofits are already struggling to get financing under the mayor's rent freeze.
COPA is only the second law Mamdani has signed. A watered-down successor to a version Mayor Eric Adams vetoed, it passed quietly through the City Council. The Post says it is also a test of the courts. In a landmark 1976 case over the city's attempt to rezone private land in Tudor City, New York's Court of Appeals ruled that cities must be "reasonable" when regulating private property, a standard the editorial says should strike COPA down. It also calls the law a partial "taking" of property under the Fifth Amendment, and concludes that it is "another example of how the left pretends it's battling for justice when its real struggle is simply for power."
SOURCES
UPDATES
Nov 14 · 3:32 PM ET
Published.
