Back to Israel

OPINION: What the hatred of Jews reveals about the haters, from Hamas's charter to a plot against a Manhattan synagogue

FACTS

In an op-ed for JNS, Aaron J. Shuster argues that the hatred aimed at Jews by Islamist movements says more about the people who hold it than about the Jews they target.

The argument (per JNS): - He opens with the Nov. 10 indictment in New York of three men charged with terrorism in support of Iran's IRGC and Kata'ib Hezbollah. Prosecutors say the alleged targets included a Manhattan synagogue and a British air base housing American forces. "The presence of American forces explains targeting the airbase. But why the people who prayed at the Manhattan synagogue?" (The defendants are presumed innocent.) - Drawing on Carl Jung, he proposes a test: "Take the conduct a man condemns and ask what he calls it when it serves his own cause." - Hamas's 1988 charter, he writes, cited both the forged Protocols of the Elders of Zion and a hadith about stones and trees giving away hiding Jews. "The covenant needs the Jew to be immensely powerful when it explains what has gone wrong and helpless when it imagines putting things right." - He points to the Oct. 7 recording in which a terrorist calls his parents to boast that he killed 10 Jews "with his own hands," and to Houthi summer camps where children chant curses against Jews in a country where almost none remain. - On the synagogue plot: nothing a worshiper could say about the war or his own life would have mattered to the plotters "if being Jewish was enough."

SOURCES

UPDATES

  1. 7:24 AM ET

    Published.