Writing in the Washington Examiner, physician and policy writer Eric Wargotz takes aim at House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries's call to "clean up the mess at the Supreme Court." Jeffries, he argues, is channeling a caucus agenda built around bills from Reps. Hank Johnson, Jamie Raskin and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: an externally enforced ethics code, strict gift bans, 18-year term limits by statute, and "the lurking threat of court expansion."
Wargotz says those measures would "accomplish the exact opposite" of restoring trust. Letting outside investigators police sitting justices would hand a partisan Congress a weapon to "harass or intimidate justices whose legal opinions they dislike." Term limits that guarantee every president two picks would make confirmation fights "an institutionalized, permanent feature of every single national election cycle" and bring "constitutional whiplash" as core doctrines shift. Court-packing, he writes, is "worst of all," setting off an arms race that would reduce the Court to "a mere auxiliary panel of Congress."
His alternative: formal recusal rules with written explanations when a justice declines to step aside, bipartisan limits and signed opinions for major emergency-docket rulings, and, if the country really wants fixed terms, a constitutional amendment rather than "a flimsy statutory trick." His conclusion: "The Democratic caucus's current proposals mistake political dominance over the court for institutional reform."
SOURCES
UPDATES
9:09 AM ET
Published.
